Secular Right

As I pointed out in my last post, many don’t understand people who can behave morally without belief in the big man in the sky. Trying to explain a conservative atheist to believers is above my pay grade.

People ask me how, as an atheist I can support people like the born-again Sarah Palin. Some think defending the inviolability of marriage between a man and a woman, or protecting and respecting life requires a belief in god. I happen to agree with the religious right’s political goals for different reasons. There are many traditions in this country we should want to conserve, and nit-picking about the “why” is not only counter-productive but plain silly.

And since the Prop 8 haters want to co-opt the ancient word of marriage, I’m going to redefine “coming out” and encourage my righty friends and readers to come out and find other like minds.

Perfectly timed, there is a new blog, written in part by John Derbyshire, called Secular Right. I’ll be reading it, and you should too.


You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

AddThis Social Bookmark Button

27 Responses to “Secular Right”

  1. You probably know how I feel about atheists (I am unsettled about the topic – especially since their moral Locus of Control has a tendency to become internal). But a persons belief system is not static. It’s got a magnitude and vector to it.

    The question is: From whence you came and to which direction are you going? You can judge that in a person by what they say and what they do.

    There are Christians I do not choose to associate with even though they are on my ‘team’. There are those of Jewish extraction whom I could call brothers and sisters. Could I not do the same about an atheist? Are they not also capable of being seekers of truth, though their road is a harsh and unforgiving one?

    Don’t I also consider you, Moxie, a friend?

  2. I think Aaron put it quite well:

    “Judaism holds that righteous Gentiles merit heaven. It’s the primary reason Judaism eschews proselytizing. Better to be a righteous Gentile than a convert to Judaism who can’t handle giving up bacon double cheeseburgers or keeping the Sabbath. Righteous laypeople are better than lapsed clergy. Considering clergy to be “superior” servants of God is a mistake. ”

    “We need to aim for “my [fill in the blanks] is of unimpeachable character and decency, and happens to be a [occupation]”.”

    http://moxie.nu/?p=1704

    I would assume that you would be called a Gentile. You’ld have to ask Aaron about that.
    __________________________________

    Though he (Aaron) speaks of God with form, perhaps you have an understanding of god(lessness) ‘without form’… or formlessness (or essenceless).

    I could be speaking out of turn, but this is my way of reaching out to an atheist (you) that I like very much.

    Time to switch my right-brain off. ;)

  3. Atheist Conservatives…

    Today, Moxie mentioned a blog started by some atheist conservatives called Secular Right. For those who may not be regular readers of Moxie’s, she is an atheist who was raised as a Catholic ……

  4. CondO, I do not proselytize my godless ways and hold respect and even admiration for believers in currently peaceful religions.

    Someday I’ll write a post about why I rejected religion, belief in god, and still believe people can led moral, ethical lives without the promise (or threat) of a supernatural being. Also, how in some ways, it’s actually more meaningful, given that we don’t expect a pat on the back or some sort of eternal reward in the afterlife.

    But not today, too much to do :(

  5. For me, I don’t think about ‘scoring points for the afterlife’. Its seems too much of a simplification of the way things are. There are people who live their life that way. Hopefully they will outgrow it.

    The older I get, the more I wonder about existence/nonexistence after death and the whole silliness of Angels with wings and sitting on clouds strumming harps and all that sort of nonsense.

    I think for us people to contemplate death on this side of the ‘River Jordan’ is like asking “what is life like 5 miles north of the North Pole. The question is meaningless.” (Quote by Stephan Hawking in regards to the composition of the Universe moments before the Big Bang).

    … and the idea that G_d is in the form of a man with a white beard living in the clouds – that’s for kids. I think we can all agree on that.

    Though I am Catholic, and I do believe in spirituality, I do feel that our viewpoint is way over simplified and caricaturized by those who are hostile to Catholicism (or religion for that matter). You don’t strike me as hostile, btw.

    It will be interesting to hear your viewpoint as to why you’ve chosen the path you have. Considering your polite disagreement with us who do believe in God, I will be more apt to have ears to hear what you say.

    Thanks for reaching out, Moxie.

    “To thine own self be true.”

  6. Well Condo,I have to disagree with you!….I know theres angels.They are ALLWAYS looking out for me…………..Nino

  7. Nino, you are one person I believe really does have angels!!

  8. Excellent post, Moxie… and great comments as well. I love your comment on how living a moral, ethical life as an atheist can be more meaningful without the expectation of some eternal reward in return.

    I had never considered that before, and I think it’s a great model for both non-believers AND believers to follow; to be good for the sake of being good, and improving the world around you. Of course the intangible reward that follows is a sense of satisfaction and peace in life.

    I really like that. Thank you for your insight!

  9. I’m an atheist, cro-magnon conservative. I have no problems with religion and people who are religtious. I do want all to respect my thoughts, as I do theirs. I see issues like abortion and gay marriage as something that needs to be separated from political debate. How ever right or wrong (I have problems with abortion, I have no problems with people marrying who they love) issues like these have had a serious negative effect on the conservative movement. Think about it, there’s a lot of fence sitters who look upon single issue abortion types and scurry the other way, and no matter what Rush Limbaugh and Sean Hannity say, we can have a conservative movement that includes another 10% of the population.

    There should be no surprise that atheists would find it imperative to live an honorable, honest and moral life. It is crucial to the mindset. Without it, we’re just beings floating around looking for an angle, if you will.

  10. “Well Condo,I have to disagree with you!….I know theres angels.”

    S’okay, Nino.

    I believe in angels too. To me, they are purely spiritual beings (no form - or formlessness). I just have a hard time with the modern day imagery of what they supposedly ‘look’ like: wings, long flowing hair, and curvaceous …. well… never mind. ;)

  11. “I know theres angels.They are ALLWAYS looking out for me…………..Nino”

    …and you are probably someone who can be alone and not be lonely. Thats awesome.

    Not many people have faith as strong as yours.

  12. I know there are angels, because Moxie is one! :)

  13. “I know there are angels, because Moxie is one! ”

    Yes… she definately fits the modern imagery of one, doesn’t she? Minus the wings, of course….

  14. Yep… minus the wings… heh…

    http://moxie.nu/?p=1749

  15. Ed Bonderenka Says:

    I don’t want to sound condescending.
    I was once an atheist.
    I did not use it as an excuse to promote my own self-interest over that of others for lack of fear of punishment. Therefore I can recognize that others (like our hostess, the DuToits, etc.) might act similarly.
    However, that left me without a compass for social mores, except for what I internally felt was “right” or “wrong”. Liberal social policy looked generous and kind-hearted.
    Perhaps if I’d had more of an exposure to conservative thought then, I would have thought different.
    It was only after I became convinced there was a “Master” of creation that I sought His opinion on the matter. And conformed. And then saw the wisdom of it.
    If other Christians had a similar path, it would explain our surprise that someone could come to a socially conservative position (economically conservative is easy as it can be seen as self-serving)) without the same guidance.

  16. […] Moxie (”Perfectly timed… I’ll be reading it, and you should too.”) […]

  17. As a Christian, I’m embarrassed when people who call themselves Christians act like jerks. Most Christians recognize that there are many atheists and agnostics who act the way that we should.

  18. I once, a long time ago, fell away from Christianity.

    I became Agnostic and even dabbled in Atheistic thoughts. Since then, I have strove to return to the church - so I know where I am headed.

    Its been a hard journey for me - especially since my faith in the unseen (spirituality) is very limited. So, like a blind man who can barely discern light from dark, I continue to struggle on towards that light - what ever it may be.

    Doing good works daily - without expectation of rewards is a lot like facing that light. It takes a lot of practice and self discovery of all those hidden intentions, but I am aware that progress has been made.

    But there are rewards for facing the light:

    I do good works because if I didn’t, I would cease to exist.

    Or, more precisely, I would despair of life and make an end of it.

    Good works give me hope. Proof-positive that there is good in this world and that life, in this good world, is worth living.

    Lets just call it Spiritual Life Support …and is time and money well spent due to its life giving properties.

    Perhaps, this is what Ralph Waldo Emerson was talking about when he wrote his poem called “Success” (which is counter intuitive to the ’success’ of todays standards):
    ____________________________________________

    To laugh often and much;
    to win the respect of intelligent people
    and the affection of children;
    to earn the appreciation of honest critics
    and endure the betrayal of false friends;
    to appreciate beauty; to find the best in others;
    to leave the world a bit better,
    whether by a healthy child,
    a garden patch
    or a redeemed social condition;
    to know even one life has breathed easier
    because you have lived.
    This is to have succeeded.

    http://www.chebucto.ns.ca/Philosophy/Sui-Generis/Emerson/success.htm
    ________________________________________

    There are variations of this theme on the above linked website. All are very good.

    Have a very nice Thanksgiving Holiday, dear sweet moxie. :)

  19. This may be a good time to repost a video I put in the comments a couple of months ago – because it is precisely how I feel about living sometimes:

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dn7_tho2vUI (* It starts at ~1:12*)

    “Dear god, whose name I do not know, thank you for my life. I forgot how big…”

  20. I never seen that movie Condo.I like Tom Hanks hes a very good actor i’ll have to rent it………..Nino

  21. I think Joe Vs the Volcano is an acquired taste. You’ll either _really_ like it or _really_ hate it.

    Just thought I’d warn you, Nino.

    Personally, I liked it (as you can tell)…

  22. Condo said-

    But there are rewards for facing the light:

    I do good works because if I didn’t, I would cease to exist.

    Or, more precisely, I would despair of life and make an end of it.

    Geeze, condo I am so moved! A tear is welling. Do you really think like this? Do people laugh at you when you speak? How did Jim Jones miss handing you a cupa?

  23. People who are comfortable abdicating their personal responsibility and intellectual curiosity to the constraints and edicts of religious dogma and (generally) a belief in a “supreme” being are certainly entitled to do so. I just wish they would do it in private, stop telling me they are “right” that they see the light and I am wrong and in the dark, stop demanding tax relief to help them support their mission, stop killing people for disagreeing or telling them they will endure pain and suffering, stop demanding additional parking spaces and violating local zoning codes, stop talking about our “Christian Nation”, it is not, stop insisting our legal system is based on the 10 commandments, stop confusing religion with science, stop invoking god’s name to help make a free throw, or war on innocent Iraqi’s, stop demanding concessions in the work place, keep their noses out of the legislative process trying to further their beliefs and imposing them on all citizens and finally, for god’s sake stop , insisting that without god and his punitive hand or glorious afterlife, mankind will be incapable of having a properly aligned moral compass. Western religion insists that adults sans religion are no better than children raised by wolves at controlling their impulses. This is very, very demeaning to those, like our hostess, who spit the Kool-Aid on the sidewalk. Atheists never confuse the outcome of their behavior as having something to do with the will of god, never believe that anything ever happened because god thought it was a good idea or favored someone or some country because of their beliefs. Loosing god, in fact, make life much easier to comprehend.

  24. Who’s talking the about the will of god, strawman? Show me where my actions are the ‘will of god’.

    Those are my choices.

    Mine.

    You have no idea how much of an ass you sound like right now.

    I could out-atheist you in a heart beat you self serving degenerate.

  25. oh… and ribbit. =)

  26. “Do you really think like this? ”

    Come to think of it, I think that would be a good base for a character in a story. Specifically, the hero. ;)

    “Do people laugh at you when you speak?”

    Nah… though I have come across severe opposition. Oh no… nothing like your pathetic gestures, my poor troll. I’m talkin people who’ve had crime record(s) a mile long.

    Yes, I’ve been chumped a few times… but never by you sweet cakes…

Leave a Reply